Printable Version of Topic
Click here to view this topic in its original format |
Forums > Rock & Prog > Gentle Giant - 1975 Free Hand, 1993 Terrapin Trucking CD 004 |
Posted by: OlCh on 17-11-2006, 00:49 | ||||||||||||||||
cue & log tagged within, scans are inside
неуклонно продолжаем генеральную линию Прогрессивному Року - Прогрессивные формы релиза (и для другой музыки - также!) ![]() ![]() погнали дальше со спасибами runo и всем другим друзьям ![]()
Gentle Giant's "Free Hand": A Progressive Rock Classic!, December 15, 2001 Reviewer: James P. Zaworski (Joliet, IL USA) Gentle Giant is one of the most interesting progressive rock bands that has ever been. From 1970 to 1980, they put out some of the most provacative, fascinating, and musically complex music in progressive rock. In the middle of their career, they put out a release calle "Free Hand". Free Hand: Arguably their most popular album (with the possible exception of "In a Glass House"), and certainly one of their best! It was released in 1972, and is their third recording. The first track, "Just the Same", starts with the snapping of fingers, making a nice tempo, and it is then accompanied by a keyboard rhythm, and electric guitar, and then explodes into a heavy bass, drums, and vocals: "See me, What I am, What I was, What I'll be....", as Derek Shulman belts out the lyrics in his inimitable style (and subtlety accompanied by strange saxophones, clarinets, and horns). Changes and more changes, musically, rhythmically, and in time and tempo, abound throughout this catchy, strangely mellow, and at times, heavy, and excellent song. The second track is called "On Reflection", and is one that continues to display the unexpected virtousity, and inventiveness, and talent of Gentle Giant. It is a song in which all five members of the group sing, in a juxtaposed harmony that is reminiscent of Medieval English minstrel music. Lovely! (Especially Kerry Minnear's soft vocals in the middle of this song). The third track, and title track, is "Free Hand", and is my favorite song on this recording. This one is really powerful! Back is the driving bass guitar work of Ray Shulman, and the excellent guitar work of Gary Green. Also on this song are all the unexpected changes in tempo, it is like 4 or 5 songs in one! The fourth track is "Time to Kill", and starts with the sounds from the original computer game, "Pong". A medium level Giant song, it does groove in it's own way. The fifth track is "His Last Voyage", and begins with a mellow bass line, compliment by vibes and guitar, and then melding perfectly into a lovely vocal harmony, with Minnear in the lead. This is a very dreamy song, and quite ethereal. The sixth track is entitled "Talybont", is an instrumental piece, and is another of my favorite songs on this album. Again, it displays that hard-to-put-your-finger-on-quality and medieval feel that much of Gentle Giant's music is famous for. It comes complete with harpsichord, electric guitar and bass, recorder, moog synthesizers, flute, tambourine, and drums. The seventh, and final track on this recording is "Mobile", and this exhibits the kind of driving, 'rolling' heavy bass lines, raucous vocals of Derek Shulman, and soft keyboard/harpsichord work of Minnear, eclectic electric guitar work of Gary Greene, fantastic drumming of John Weathers. It is also complete and replete with the strangeness and altogether weirdness of Gentle Giant. At times, it is like they are 'punk classical', from Mozart's time, especially when the bass player, Ray Shulman, pulls out his electric violin, and has a go in the middle of the song! So, by all means, stretch the limits of your imagination, and expand your musical horizons with the boundless possibilities of Gentle Giant! |
Posted by: OlCh on 17-11-2006, 01:01 | ||
![]()
|
Posted by: retro on 17-11-2006, 01:09 |
Да, всем скучно стало! ![]() ![]() 10ХХХ!!! |
Posted by: Гордый on 17-11-2006, 06:50 | ||
![]() Я имел в виду не качество звука (оно на высоте), а муз. содержание. ![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 17-11-2006, 07:50 | ||
а я и имел в виду музыкально-поэтическое, так сказать, содержание ![]()
|
Posted by: runo on 17-11-2006, 16:59 |
На самом деле, просто, Free Hand и последующий диск 1976 года Interview, более навороченные и их с первого раз просечь тяжело! Потом будет концертный альбом 1977 года Playing The Fool , на котором многие вещи с Free Hand звучат гораздо более интересно и изысканно! К сожалению, у меня нет последних трех студийных дисков GG: The Missing Piece, Civillian и Giant For A Day. Хотя они уже не звучат так "прогрессивно" как классические диски 1972-76 гг, ради полноты коллекции было бы не дурно их заиметь! У кого-нить они имеются? |
Posted by: Гордый on 17-11-2006, 19:53 | ||
![]() ![]() ![]() |
Posted by: runo on 17-11-2006, 20:45 |
Откопал у себя американский Vertigo - Gentle Giant- Aquiring the Taste 1971 года! Если надо, то тоже раздадим! |
Posted by: OlCh on 17-11-2006, 21:26 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: runo on 17-11-2006, 21:36 |
задницу покажи плис... не свою, конечно ![]() [/QUOTE] [QUOTE=OlCh,17-11-2006, 21:26] [QUOTE=runo,17-11-2006, 18:45] Откопал у себя американский Vertigo - Gentle Giant- Aquiring the Taste 1971 года! ![]() Вот какая она! ![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 17-11-2006, 21:52 |
с такой - есть в сети, правильный рип и картинки ![]() |
Posted by: runo on 17-11-2006, 22:18 | ||
Three Friends (Columbia CK 31649) тоже не надо?! |
Posted by: OlCh on 17-11-2006, 23:03 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 18-11-2006, 11:17 | ||
без картинков, но правильный рип ![]() |
Posted by: runo on 18-11-2006, 11:25 | ||||
Но в принципе на Interview заканчивается по настоящему прогрессивный GG и начинаются эксперименты и заигрывания с коммерцией! А концертный диск 1977 года - это уже так сказать красивая лебединая песнь! ![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 18-11-2006, 12:21 |
а что кто-то сказал что это ремастер? ![]() |
Posted by: bubamara on 18-11-2006, 17:31 |
С пристрастием помучал iso. Монтировал, переименовывал в wv, проигрывал в фубаре обоими способами, картинки смотрел. Все работает. Гениально. Маэстро, тысяча благодарностей! ![]() |
Posted by: Гордый on 18-11-2006, 18:36 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 18-11-2006, 20:06 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: bubamara on 18-11-2006, 22:45 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: Гордый on 18-11-2006, 22:55 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 18-11-2006, 22:59 |
неее, идей хватит! и так по два раза пришлось кучу релизов переделать ![]() пока их всех не раздадим - идеи не принимаются! ![]() ![]() |
Posted by: Гордый on 19-11-2006, 00:36 |
А мы их в блокнотик... ![]() |
Posted by: bubamara on 19-11-2006, 01:16 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 23-11-2006, 00:58 |
боишься дедушки Ленина? "за соучастие" и т.д. ![]() |
Posted by: bertox on 07-03-2008, 08:14 |
This release sounds better than the CEMA of 1990? |
Posted by: OlCh on 07-03-2008, 08:35 |
naturlich ![]() |
Posted by: bertox on 07-03-2008, 23:28 |
Ok...why? ![]() |
Posted by: bertox on 08-03-2008, 00:40 |
Well...i find this: Which CD version of Free Hand is the best? I'm confused by the different versions! The DRT Entertainment (USA 2005) CD release is the best, with the out-of-print Terrapin (UK) CD a close second. The One Way (US) release comes from an alternate master tape with slight differences from the original album. Can you compare the remasterings of "In a Glass House" from Alucard (UK) and DRT Entertainment (USA)? They are both excellent. I have not done a close comparison. Some fans have reported that the DRT release is louder and more punchy, which some people prefer and some don't. You can't go wrong with either one. On the other hand, the DRT "Free Hand" is reportedly the best master yet, with the old Terrapin CD in second place. http://www.blazemonger.com/GG/faq.html#drt (http://www.blazemonger.com/GG/faq.html#drt The first One Way release has terrible sound quality. It is very muddy and lacks treble. Supposedly, it was not mastered from an original master tape. The Terrapin Trucking release is excellent. It is noticeably superior to the One Way releases. Even so, there were complaints about the amount of hiss on the "RGF CD" disc, so Kerry Minnear and John Weathers remastered the Terrapin disc AGAIN to reduce the amount of hiss. The disc was then given the TRUCKCD number. The difference between the RGF and TRUCKCD discs is likely very small. Defects: Both One Way discs used incorrect or poorly chosen master tapes. Both One Way discs incorrectly say that the album was made in 1972. The second One Way disc is missing the drum roll at the very end of the album. http://www.blazemonger.com/GG/quality.html#FREE%20HAND (http://www.blazemonger.com/GG/quality.html#FREE%20HAND ![]() |
Posted by: OlCh on 08-03-2008, 01:07 | ||
![]() |
Posted by: bertox on 08-03-2008, 02:56 | ||
Ok..but..btw..i think that comparing is necessary...there's a lot of same disc's different releases.. I don't want to listen music..., just want to put Gentle Giant into my 10 floor building elevator back-music.... ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Posted by: Vp36nl on 11-03-2008, 09:47 |
Спасибо! |
Posted by: Vp36nl on 19-03-2008, 09:47 |
Нет источников![]() |
Posted by: bubamara on 19-03-2008, 10:28 | ||
--- PS: к слову, один из первых iso/wv - ещё экспериментальный. И именно на нём - "вот тебе и первая выгода"© ![]() |
Posted by: Vp36nl on 19-03-2008, 11:16 |
Спасибо за поддержку. Совсем не помню этот альбом, надеюсь, что интересный. |
Posted by: havefun6699 on 19-03-2008, 13:21 |
Интересно, сравнивал ли кто-нибудь звучание первого и второго издания на Terrapin Records? Я имею ввиду имеющие номера с RGF и TRUCK? |
Posted by: bubamara on 19-03-2008, 15:26 | ||
|
Posted by: OlCh on 19-03-2008, 19:11 |
да и вообще рекомендовал бы не начинать знакомство с прог-роком с GG ![]() |
Posted by: Vp36nl on 20-03-2008, 22:37 |
Прог-рок появился, как термин, несколько позже, если не ошибаюсь. А раньше. в 80-х, этот рок называли психоделический! и пластинка GG Three Friends мне очень понравилась. Поэтому и продолжаю изучать творчество данного коллектива![]() |