Close Topic Options

Артист: Academy of Ancient Music, Andrew Manze Альбом: Handel - Concerti grossi, Op. 6, 1998 Издатель: Harmonia Mundi / HMU907228.29 Жанр: Classical Формат файла: NetLab Ссылка 1: eMule CD 1 72 clicks Ссылка 2: eMule CD 2 55 clicks Ссылка 3: Torrent Нахождение: eDonkey/Torrent

George Pratt (Classical-music.com)
These 12 concertos rank among the major pinnacles of the late Baroque. Handel wrote/recycled them (two borrow from earlier organ concertos) within a single month in 1739, for use in the theatre as interval pieces during oratorios.

Since 1993 my benchmark has been Hogwood’s lean, athletic recording with the Handel & Haydn Society. He omits Handel’s oboes and bassoon (inserted later in concertos 1, 2, 5 and 6) and adds few frills. Despite a hard-etched recorded tone, much remains irresistible.

Manze, by contrast, is irrepressible. His imagination, puckish wit and total absorption in the spirit of Handel is enthralling. He too omits wind, and also argues effectively for having no separate continuo instrument when soloists play alone: the textural contrasts with full orchestra are all the stronger. He plays constantly to the limits but, to my mind, never beyond them. So the final Allegro of Concerto No. 11 is manically energetic; the pianissimo episodes in the angular fugue of Concerto No. 2 are lovingly caressed; ornaments sound spontaneous and are often breathtakingly virtuosic. Solo trio/tutti contrasts are vivid, with Manze, Peter Lissaur and David Watkin audibly forward of the orchestra – thoughtful engineering not quite matched by a touch over-weight bass and the odd editing blip.

Standage and Collegium Musicum 90 are polished, stylish, and more respectful - they don’t live dangerously, as Manze does. They are, though, coloured with Handel’s optional wind, appearing on this last disc of three in the additional concerto Handel included in a performance of Alexander’s Feast.

SPOILER (EAC)

SPOILER (CD1) CODE Exact Audio Copy V1.0 beta 2 from 29. April 2011 EAC extraction logfile from 24. September 2011, 19:42 Academy of Ancient Music / Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD1) Used drive  : PLEXTOR DVDR  PX-755A  Adapter: 1  ID: 1 Read mode              : Secure Utilize accurate stream : Yes Defeat audio cache      : Yes Make use of C2 pointers : No Read offset correction                      : 30 Overread into Lead-In and Lead-Out          : No Fill up missing offset samples with silence : Yes Delete leading and trailing silent blocks  : No Null samples used in CRC calculations      : Yes Used interface                              : Installed external ASPI interface Used output format : Internal WAV Routines Sample format      : 44.100 Hz; 16 Bit; Stereo TOC of the extracted CD     Track |  Start  |  Length  | Start sector | End sector     ---------------------------------------------------------         1  |  0:00.00 |  1:39.07 |        0    |    7431          2  |  1:39.07 |  1:57.65 |      7432    |    16271          3  |  3:36.72 |  3:04.33 |    16272    |    30104          4  |  6:41.30 |  2:03.57 |    30105    |    39386          5  |  8:45.12 |  2:19.58 |    39387    |    49869          6  | 11:04.70 |  3:07.40 |    49870    |    63934          7  | 14:12.35 |  1:42.65 |    63935    |    71649          8  | 15:55.25 |  1:37.00 |    71650    |    78924          9  | 17:32.25 |  2:34.17 |    78925    |    90491        10  | 20:06.42 |  2:26.48 |    90492    |  101489        11  | 22:33.15 |  2:50.52 |    101490    |  114291        12  | 25:23.67 |  4:01.38 |    114292    |  132404        13  | 29:25.30 |  2:27.60 |    132405    |  143489        14  | 31:53.15 |  2:18.72 |    143490    |  153911        15  | 34:12.12 |  2:23.43 |    153912    |  164679        16  | 36:35.55 |  1:18.05 |    164680    |  170534        17  | 37:53.60 |  2:05.32 |    170535    |  179941        18  | 39:59.17 |  2:24.48 |    179942    |  190789        19  | 42:23.65 |  4:40.20 |    190790    |  211809        20  | 47:04.10 |  1:26.67 |    211810    |  218326        21  | 48:31.02 |  1:52.65 |    218327    |  226791        22  | 50:23.67 |  2:10.15 |    226792    |  236556        23  | 52:34.07 |  3:34.33 |    236557    |  252639        24  | 56:08.40 |  2:06.27 |    252640    |  262116        25  | 58:14.67 |  2:52.70 |    262117    |  275086        26  | 61:07.62 |  2:17.48 |    275087    |  285409        27  | 63:25.35 |  4:13.67 |    285410    |  304451        28  | 67:39.27 |  1:34.10 |    304452    |  311511        29  | 69:13.37 |  0:32.33 |    311512    |  313944        30  | 69:45.70 |  4:10.72 |    313945    |  332766        31  | 73:56.67 |  5:30.23 |    332767    |  357539  Range status and errors Selected range     Filename Z:\NetLab\Handel - Concerti grossi, Op. 6 (Academy of Ancient Music) (1998)\CD1\Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD1).wav     Peak level 85.9 %     Extraction speed 2.0 X     Range quality 99.9 %     Test CRC CA727D3F     Copy CRC CA727D3F     Copy OK No errors occurred AccurateRip summary Track  1  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [0A84FFDE]  (AR v2) Track  2  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [7C583A8B]  (AR v2) Track  3  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [BD76DC57]  (AR v2) Track  4  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [5D9D3B70]  (AR v2) Track  5  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [F8022888]  (AR v2) Track  6  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [88FE8FFF]  (AR v2) Track  7  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [FC774B9B]  (AR v2) Track  8  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [3714ED22]  (AR v2) Track  9  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [536E28DF]  (AR v2) Track 10  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [62BA9E0C]  (AR v2) Track 11  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [C07CD526]  (AR v2) Track 12  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [7CF65B2E]  (AR v2) Track 13  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [6E82754E]  (AR v2) Track 14  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [1637D41F]  (AR v2) Track 15  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [9C70165F]  (AR v2) Track 16  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [3A30A987]  (AR v2) Track 17  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [1205B13F]  (AR v2) Track 18  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [47C0DDCD]  (AR v2) Track 19  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [6F854165]  (AR v2) Track 20  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [6E95FDD7]  (AR v2) Track 21  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [8EDAC0F8]  (AR v2) Track 22  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [F83873C4]  (AR v2) Track 23  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [91FE5416]  (AR v2) Track 24  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [04213107]  (AR v2) Track 25  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [CC988981]  (AR v2) Track 26  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [E99175B6]  (AR v2) Track 27  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [B1FDB01E]  (AR v2) Track 28  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [6B22A87D]  (AR v2) Track 29  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [C7AE6258]  (AR v2) Track 30  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [2418757E]  (AR v2) Track 31  accurately ripped (confidence 3)  [55F7DA1B]  (AR v2) All tracks accurately ripped End of status report ==== Log checksum F3961C1ADF5EA8EEFD92B57D5B81489EDDB02BD256A737003B4E94A068018285 ==== SPOILER (CD2) CODE Exact Audio Copy V1.0 beta 2 from 29. April 2011 EAC extraction logfile from 24. September 2011, 23:25 Academy of Ancient Music / Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD2) Used drive  : PLEXTOR DVDR  PX-755A  Adapter: 1  ID: 1 Read mode              : Secure Utilize accurate stream : Yes Defeat audio cache      : Yes Make use of C2 pointers : No Read offset correction                      : 30 Overread into Lead-In and Lead-Out          : No Fill up missing offset samples with silence : Yes Delete leading and trailing silent blocks  : No Null samples used in CRC calculations      : Yes Used interface                              : Installed external ASPI interface Used output format : Internal WAV Routines Sample format      : 44.100 Hz; 16 Bit; Stereo TOC of the extracted CD     Track |  Start  |  Length  | Start sector | End sector     ---------------------------------------------------------         1  |  0:00.00 |  1:07.15 |        0    |    5039          2  |  1:07.15 |  2:41.30 |      5040    |    17144          3  |  3:48.45 |  2:50.02 |    17145    |    29896          4  |  6:38.47 |  3:57.10 |    29897    |    47681          5  | 10:35.57 |  2:59.15 |    47682    |    61121          6  | 13:34.72 |  3:16.30 |    61122    |    75851          7  | 16:51.27 |  1:37.00 |    75852    |    83126          8  | 18:28.27 |  4:46.60 |    83127    |  104636          9  | 23:15.12 |  2:51.05 |    104637    |  117466        10  | 26:06.17 |  2:38.20 |    117467    |  129336        11  | 28:44.37 |  2:33.18 |    129337    |  140829        12  | 31:17.55 |  2:53.27 |    140830    |  153831        13  | 34:11.07 |  2:13.30 |    153832    |  163836        14  | 36:24.37 |  2:39.40 |    163837    |  175801        15  | 39:04.02 |  1:20.28 |    175802    |  181829        16  | 40:24.30 |  3:19.15 |    181830    |  196769        17  | 43:43.45 |  3:10.55 |    196770    |  211074        18  | 46:54.25 |  1:57.70 |    211075    |  219919        19  | 48:52.20 |  1:33.07 |    219920    |  226901        20  | 50:25.27 |  1:51.55 |    226902    |  235281        21  | 52:17.07 |  5:39.28 |    235282    |  260734        22  | 57:56.35 |  1:23.17 |    260735    |  266976        23  | 59:19.52 |  1:59.73 |    266977    |  275974        24  | 61:19.50 |  1:02.05 |    275975    |  280629        25  | 62:21.55 |  2:52.42 |    280630    |  293571        26  | 65:14.22 |  1:19.03 |    293572    |  299499        27  | 66:33.25 |  1:46.07 |    299500    |  307456        28  | 68:19.32 |  2:48.70 |    307457    |  320126        29  | 71:08.27 |  3:38.00 |    320127    |  336476        30  | 74:46.27 |  0:49.53 |    336477    |  340204        31  | 75:36.05 |  2:09.67 |    340205    |  349946  Range status and errors Selected range     Filename Z:\NetLab\Handel - Concerti grossi, Op. 6 (Academy of Ancient Music) (1998)\CD2\Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD2).wav     Peak level 94.2 %     Extraction speed 2.0 X     Range quality 99.9 %     Test CRC 1DD2F0E5     Copy CRC 1DD2F0E5     Copy OK No errors occurred AccurateRip summary Track  1  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [FAC7EA6C]  (AR v1) Track  2  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [A8445B28]  (AR v1) Track  3  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [6B710B0F]  (AR v1) Track  4  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [FD7A0AA4]  (AR v1) Track  5  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [1E2F5095]  (AR v1) Track  6  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [90940E41]  (AR v1) Track  7  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [3D356A6B]  (AR v1) Track  8  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [A2D0F20D]  (AR v1) Track  9  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [A371D692]  (AR v1) Track 10  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [1B4065CE]  (AR v1) Track 11  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [CD01E479]  (AR v1) Track 12  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [B2A9A3E5]  (AR v1) Track 13  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [70F964F1]  (AR v1) Track 14  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [2C314D49]  (AR v1) Track 15  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [46DD7170]  (AR v1) Track 16  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [3DACD5F3]  (AR v1) Track 17  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [EFADED49]  (AR v1) Track 18  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [28FA0645]  (AR v1) Track 19  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [2247E470]  (AR v1) Track 20  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [1C940696]  (AR v1) Track 21  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [D3C51E1D]  (AR v1) Track 22  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [FD3BAD67]  (AR v1) Track 23  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [EDAF642B]  (AR v1) Track 24  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [4DB50DD6]  (AR v1) Track 25  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [7BFB50FE]  (AR v1) Track 26  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [A0CB44C0]  (AR v1) Track 27  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [2EE7E274]  (AR v1) Track 28  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [880F0ABE]  (AR v1) Track 29  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [7147BFCD]  (AR v1) Track 30  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [9E62A26B]  (AR v1) Track 31  accurately ripped (confidence 8)  [570975C8]  (AR v1) All tracks accurately ripped End of status report ==== Log checksum 590DB6063A2AC1D7F6AA609C51BA45BAD1630DEDC334EAFAE43641001F220E57 ====

SPOILER (CUE)

SPOILER (CUE CD1) CODE REM GENRE Classical REM DATE 1998 REM DISCID BF129F1F REM COMMENT ExactAudioCopy v1.0b2 PERFORMER "Academy of Ancient Music" TITLE "Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD1)" FILE "Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD1).wv" WAVE   TRACK 01 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.5 in D major, HWV 323; I."     INDEX 01 00:00:00   TRACK 02 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 01:39:07   TRACK 03 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Presto"     INDEX 01 03:36:72   TRACK 04 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Largo"     INDEX 01 06:41:30   TRACK 05 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Allegro"     INDEX 01 08:45:12   TRACK 06 AUDIO     TITLE "VI. Menuet"     INDEX 01 11:04:70   TRACK 07 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.1 in G major, HWV 319; I. A tempo giusto"     INDEX 00 14:09:30     INDEX 01 14:12:35   TRACK 08 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 15:55:25   TRACK 09 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Adagio"     INDEX 01 17:32:25   TRACK 10 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Allegro"     INDEX 01 20:06:42   TRACK 11 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Allegro"     INDEX 01 22:33:15   TRACK 12 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.2 in F major, HWV 320; I. Andante larghetto"     INDEX 00 25:20:11     INDEX 01 25:23:67   TRACK 13 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 29:25:30   TRACK 14 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Largo"     INDEX 01 31:53:15   TRACK 15 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Allegro, ma non troppo"     INDEX 01 34:12:12   TRACK 16 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.3 in E minor, HWV 321; I. Larghetto"     INDEX 00 36:32:37     INDEX 01 36:35:55   TRACK 17 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Andante"     INDEX 01 37:53:60   TRACK 18 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Allegro"     INDEX 01 39:59:17   TRACK 19 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Polonaise"     INDEX 01 42:23:65   TRACK 20 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Allegro, ma non troppo"     INDEX 01 47:04:10   TRACK 21 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.10 in D minor, HWV 328; I. Ouverture"     INDEX 00 48:28:00     INDEX 01 48:31:02   TRACK 22 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 50:23:67   TRACK 23 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Lento"     INDEX 01 52:34:07   TRACK 24 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Allegro"     INDEX 01 56:08:40   TRACK 25 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Allegro"     INDEX 01 58:14:67   TRACK 26 AUDIO     TITLE "VI. Allegro moderato"     INDEX 01 61:07:62   TRACK 27 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.11 in A major, HWV 329; I. Andante larghetto, e staccato"     INDEX 00 63:20:56     INDEX 01 63:25:35   TRACK 28 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 67:39:27   TRACK 29 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Largo, et staccato"     INDEX 01 69:13:37   TRACK 30 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Andante"     INDEX 01 69:45:70   TRACK 31 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Allegro"     INDEX 01 73:56:67 SPOILER (CUE CD2) CODE REM GENRE Classical REM DATE 1998 REM DISCID CD12391F REM COMMENT ExactAudioCopy v1.0b2 PERFORMER "Academy of Ancient Music" TITLE "Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD2)" FILE "Handel - Concerti grossi, Op.6 (CD2).wv" WAVE   TRACK 01 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.7 in B-flat major, HWV 325; I. Largo"     INDEX 01 00:00:00   TRACK 02 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 01:07:15   TRACK 03 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Largo, e piano"     INDEX 01 03:48:45   TRACK 04 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Andante"     INDEX 01 06:38:47   TRACK 05 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Hornpipe"     INDEX 01 10:35:57   TRACK 06 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.6 in G minor, HWV 324; I. Larghetto e affettuoso"     INDEX 00 13:30:30     INDEX 01 13:34:72   TRACK 07 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro, ma non troppo"     INDEX 01 16:51:27   TRACK 08 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Musette"     INDEX 00 18:27:17     INDEX 01 18:28:27   TRACK 09 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Allegro"     INDEX 01 23:15:12   TRACK 10 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Allegro"     INDEX 01 26:06:17   TRACK 11 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.4 in A minor, HWV 322; I. Larghetto affettuoso"     INDEX 00 28:40:15     INDEX 01 28:44:37   TRACK 12 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 31:17:55   TRACK 13 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Largo, e piano"     INDEX 01 34:11:07   TRACK 14 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Allegro"     INDEX 01 36:24:37   TRACK 15 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.9 in F major, HWV 327; I. Largo"     INDEX 00 39:02:32     INDEX 01 39:04:02   TRACK 16 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 40:24:30   TRACK 17 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Larghetto"     INDEX 00 43:42:45     INDEX 01 43:43:45   TRACK 18 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Allegro"     INDEX 01 46:54:25   TRACK 19 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Menuet"     INDEX 01 48:52:20   TRACK 20 AUDIO     TITLE "VI. Gigue"     INDEX 01 50:25:27   TRACK 21 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.8 in C minor, HWV 326; I. Allemande"     INDEX 00 52:12:67     INDEX 01 52:17:07   TRACK 22 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Grave"     INDEX 01 57:56:35   TRACK 23 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Andante allegro"     INDEX 01 59:19:52   TRACK 24 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Adagio"     INDEX 01 61:19:50   TRACK 25 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Siciliana"     INDEX 01 62:21:55   TRACK 26 AUDIO     TITLE "VI. Allegro"     INDEX 00 65:13:10     INDEX 01 65:14:22   TRACK 27 AUDIO     TITLE "Concerto Grosso No.12 in B minor, HWV 330; I. Largo"     INDEX 00 66:30:40     INDEX 01 66:33:25   TRACK 28 AUDIO     TITLE "II. Allegro"     INDEX 01 68:19:32   TRACK 29 AUDIO     TITLE "III. Larghetto, e piano"     INDEX 01 71:08:27   TRACK 30 AUDIO     TITLE "IV. Largo"     INDEX 01 74:46:27   TRACK 31 AUDIO     TITLE "V. Allegro"     INDEX 01 75:36:05

SPOILER (Back,CD)

А вот это исполнение совсем не понравилось. Сравнивал с исполнением от Camerata Romana. У Manze с академией получилось слишком быстро и без чувства.
Надо будет с Collegium Musicum 90 сравнить...

QUOTE (Гордый @ 28-09-2011, 10:21)

А вот это исполнение совсем не понравилось. Сравнивал с исполнением от Camerata Romana. У Manze с академией получилось слишком быстро и без чувства. Надо будет с Collegium Musicum 90 сравнить...

Очень хорошая работа. В Португалии обнять благодарности.

А у кого есть Collegium Musicum 90, я здесь только один диск нашёл (мне понравилось).
Правда мне уже пообещали рип сделать

Гордый а с Avison Ensemble не сравнивал?